Should I Get Lab Diamond or Moissanite for My Engagement Ring?
Updated 16 November 2026
Choosing an engagement ring often comes down to a simple question: do you want a diamond, or do you prefer the look and price of moissanite? Both can make a lovely ring, but they are different materials, with different ways of handling light.
At Lily Arkwright, we offer both lab grown diamonds and our own Lily Arkwright Moissanites, so you can compare them in the shapes and settings you like.
Start with how the stone looks to you, then compare its measurements and the price of the complete ring. The photographs below show different designs and sizes; they are useful for seeing a ring on a hand, but are not a scale or a controlled comparison of sparkle.
The Lulu 10x8mm Elongated Cushion Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring has an elongated outline and a plain band that keeps the centre stone in view.
What Are Lab Grown Diamonds?
Lab grown diamonds are diamonds grown under controlled conditions. They have essentially the same chemical, physical and optical properties as natural diamonds, although specialist testing can identify differences associated with their growth. When comparing individual stones, consider cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight.
Ask to see the report for the diamond you are buying. Report formats vary: GIA introduced Premium and Standard quality assessments for its colourless to near-colourless lab-grown diamond service in October 2025. Check the issuing laboratory, report date and measurements rather than assuming every report uses identical grades.
A lab-grown origin does not, by itself, establish a stone’s environmental impact or the working conditions in its supply chain. If these matter to your choice, ask what evidence is available for the particular stone.
The plain band of the Isabella 4ct Oval Lab Diamond Engagement Ring leaves the oval centre as the focus.
What Is Moissanite?
Moissanite is silicon carbide, rather than diamond’s crystalline carbon. The moissanite used in jewellery is laboratory-grown. At Lily Arkwright, we offer our own premium Lily Arkwright Moissanites, which are available in a choice of shapes and settings.
Moissanite has higher dispersion than diamond: it separates light into colours more strongly, which can give it noticeable rainbow flashes. Diamonds also show coloured flashes as well as white light. The cut and lighting affect what you see in either stone.
Some people love moissanite’s colourful fire; others prefer the appearance of a diamond. Try both in daylight and ordinary indoor lighting, rather than choosing from a single brightly lit photograph.
The Lulu 9x9mm Square Cushion Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring combines a square outline with softened corners and a simple yellow-gold band.
How Do Size and Price Compare?
Carat measures weight, while millimetres describe a stone’s dimensions. Moissanite listings may use diamond equivalent weight (DEW), a comparison with a similarly sized diamond rather than the moissanite’s actual weight. For a fairer visual comparison, look at stones of the same shape and compare their length and width in millimetres.
Compare current quotes for the complete rings, including the metal, setting and any side stones. A lower centre-stone price does not tell you the final difference between two designs, and there is no fixed saving that applies to every lab diamond and moissanite.
If you are also considering a natural diamond engagement ring, keep its origin and any rarity premium separate from the appearance you prefer. Choose a ring within a budget you are comfortable with, without relying on a future resale value.
The Lily Arkwright Eden 2.5ct Round Lab Diamond Engagement Ring pairs a round centre with a twisting, stone-set band.
Can Either Stone Be Worn Every Day?
Diamond ranks 10 on the Mohs hardness scale and moissanite around 9.25. This describes resistance to scratching, not resistance to every kind of damage. Both can be used in engagement rings, but neither the stone nor its setting is indestructible.
Take your ring off for activities that could knock or put pressure on it, and have a loose stone or damaged claw checked before wearing it again. The security and condition of the setting matter as much as the hardness of the centre stone.
Small stones along the band add detail around the oval centre of the Lily Arkwright Allure 9x7mm Oval Moissanite Engagement Ring.
Compare the Stones in a Finished Ring
An enlarged photograph can show details that are much less noticeable at normal viewing distance. It also cannot tell you how a ring feels on your hand. Compare the overall outline, the height of the setting and whether the band feels comfortable alongside another ring.
Once you have a shortlist, see how each stone works in a beautifully designed engagement ring.
The Lily Arkwright Engagement Ring Collection includes different shapes and settings to help you narrow down the look you prefer.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose a lab diamond if having a diamond is important to you. Choose moissanite if you enjoy its appearance and the options it gives you within your budget. You do not need to prefer whichever stone looks bigger in a photograph.
Before deciding, compare the actual dimensions, confirm the centre and side-stone materials, and check the final price for your chosen configuration.
If you would like to compare designs, our expert jewellery consultants can help you work through the stone sizes, settings and reports relevant to your shortlist.
































































































